I remember being a trainee teacher back in 2005 and going in to observe lessons. The lessons were pretty good, by whatever measure you might use. But I didn’t learn a lot from being there. Like someone with no technological knowledge inspecting the inside of a mechanical object, I just didn’t know what I was looking at.
I mention this because I think observing lessons is actually brilliant. I learn a lot from observing colleagues and I gain a lot from the feedback I receive, when they observe me. So why doesn’t this work for trainees, or even Early Career Teachers for that matter?
I think it comes down to experience. When an experienced teacher observes someone, they can watch the lesson and decide what they would do differently and why they would do it that way, drawing from their own classroom practice.
A trainee or inexperienced teacher cannot do this anywhere near as effectively or independently, in most cases. This is problematic for our trainees. We expect them to go into lessons, taught by our colleagues and expect them to soak up all of the good practice they witness, without realising that they simply aren’t equipped to do so.
So let’s equip them.
Here are some useful questions for trainees and Early Career Teachers to consider when observing. Hopefully, by getting them to reflect on their answers, we might help to focus their attention on what matters.
Lesson Observation Questions
- Has the teacher demonstrated that they have high expectations for behaviour and progress? How did they convey this?
- Does there appear to be a routine being followed? If so, what is it?
- Is the classroom environment suited to the task? (e.g. grouped tables, equipment, use of space, etc)
- How long does the teacher allow the students to work for, before checking progress?
- Does the teacher model answers for the class? (If so, what was good about the modelling?)
- What standard of answer does the teacher expect from the students?
- How variable is the standard of answer from the students (and how does the teacher respond to this)?
- When challenged by disruption, rudeness, etc, how does the teacher respond? How effective was the behaviour management strategy? (Did it work? Quickly?)
- How many students are checked for progress during the lesson?
- How often does the teacher ask questions? (What follow-up questions are asked?)
- How could the students’ learning be stretched further?
- How could the students’ learning be supported further?
This isn’t an exhaustive list, but it gives students something to concentrate their attention on. When they begin their own teaching, these questions will naturally form part of the feedback on routines, expectations, behaviour, progress, differentiation and assessment. Having clear anecdotes to return to from their own observations, will help trainees and Early Career Teachers to compare their practice to the practice of experienced staff.
With any luck, they might even learn from us.
What other questions would you add to the list?
Leave a reply below, or send me a tweet!
You can find me on Twitter @guruteaching. Say hi!